Ithaca Greek Mediterranean Restaurant

Our first visit to Ithaca was wonderful! We’ll be back and are telling everyone who will listen, what a terrific experience we had. All staff are so friendly and gracious that it felt like we were in their home. The meals were beautifully prepared and presented and brought to the table with such a sense of pride and fun. We had many questions and each were answered with patience and and an ease of knowledge. Our family and friends cannot thank you enough!

Always a great experience here. I have been coming here with my family for over ten years and never once have I had a bad experience.

This place is GRE...

This place is GREAT. Love love love the Greek salad and crave the Gyros. Wonderful welcoming atmosphere. Highly recommend.

AWFULL EXPERIENCE, NEVER AGAIN!!

This was an experience not to forget! To start off the service was REALLY poor, the "New" waitress that was serving our table, not only looked miserable, and looked like she wanted to walk out, but gave off so much attitude that we were afraid to even ask for a glass of water! She took our order and than suddenly dissapeared! The Hummus arrived with no bread and one spoon on the side of the dish, thus the order of coke had not yet arrived. The Gyro dinner which we were told that could feed two very hungry people, could not even satisfy half of me! Very stinchy with the serving size, two small potatoes, a handfull of cold rice, and than finally some cold extremely greasy gyro slices! AWFULL!! I WILL NEVER GO BACK!!! DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY AND TIME IN THIS PLACE!!!!

Been here twice, and the same story each time...

Been here twice, and the same story each time. The service was slow, the food was only average (I am talking on par with the food court in the mall across the street), the bathrooms were not clean and operable and overall it was not a good valentine's day experience. As the only Greek restaurant in the area, you guys must improve a great deal, or I will never go back again

I took my guests to the worst place possible.BAD...

I took my guests to the worst place possible.BAD food,Worst service.Sorry but you are NOT RECCOMENDED.TERRIBLE!!!!

Very bad service. They can't handle large...

Very bad service. They can't handle large parties. I will never go back. I don't recommend this place to anyone.

Very bad and old food.Who is the chef?Will never...

Very bad and old food.Who is the chef?Will never return.Who writes your reviews?I think you do.We'll never return.

The food was freshly made and it was hot...

The food was freshly made and it was hot, something you'd rarely find at restaurants these days. The pitas were warm when they came, and went great with the dips. The portions were huge, (and by huge I mean huge), the owner was very friendly, and offered advice on greek desserts. I would definitely recommend this restaurant. It is a hidden gem in Markham.

Very old-style sixties Greek atmosphere, kind of...

Very old-style sixties Greek atmosphere, kind of cool, though. Only three tables occupied when we were there, but we thought the food was really good; a nice light dressing and loads of feta on the salad and a very big stack of gyros meat, even though it was the small portion.